Searching for income in today’s market environment feels a bit like hunting for that cool oasis of water in a parched desert. It can be difficult to find, but not impossible.
High-quality yields have never been lower in the U.S. and globally as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and resulting economic downdraft. Key global policy interest rates are anchored near zero or even at negative levels. Central banks, led by the Federal Reserve (Fed), are buying trillions of dollars in government bonds, driving down yields to support the economy and markets.
The Fed also recently made two rate cuts, lowering the Fed funds rate to a range of 0 to 0.25%.
It is possible, however, with diversification and measured risks, for investors to find income without unduly endangering principal.
There are two main avenues to obtain more income. The first is to own longer maturity fixed-income securities which have higher duration. (Duration refers to a debt instrument’s price sensitivity to changes in interest rates – the higher the duration the greater the sensitivity.)
Higher-duration securities typically pay greater yields because they carry more interest rate risk and day-to-day volatility. These are usually bonds with fixed payouts and a long time to maturity, so every change in interest rates significantly impacts their value. They tend to do poorly when interest rates are rising.
Seeking greater yield through duration, however, is not attractive at present as interest rates on long-maturity investments are not significantly higher than interest rates on short-maturity investments, so the opportunity for additional yield is small. This is unlikely to change in the near term with the economy on the mend from the deep recession triggered by the pandemic.
Whether the recovery is a V-shaped, U-shaped or some other shape, the Fed is firmly committed to low rates for at least a few years.
The repercussions are two-fold. First, high-quality government bonds offer scant yield in either short- or long-maturity bonds. Second, interest-rate risks are asymmetric with yields this low. Treasury rates have little room to fall, but plenty of room to rise over the long term and trigger lower bonds prices once the economy heats up and the Fed eventually begins to raise rates.
Another route to generating higher income is to take on credit risk, which carries a higher risk of default and price volatility. Credit risks certainly have risen with the economic slowdown. The recession already has sparked a wave of defaults in lower-quality bonds and leveraged loans.
The key question for investors is whether market pricing and yields already reflect this. We believe they do. Fixed-income markets have priced in an increase in defaults in line with consensus default estimates. The key risk to credit then is if the economy recovers much more slowly than expected.
For income investors, we think the implication is clear – taking diversified and measured risks in mid- to lower-quality securities may offer a better source of income than higher-duration securities. Additionally, it helps to diversify across asset types, such as corporate bonds, emerging markets and securitized assets linked to mortgages or other assets.
Currently, most savings and money market accounts offered by banks pay little more than 0%, and most bank certificates of deposit (CDs) offer yields under 1%.
For investors with a longer-term outlook – particularly if you’re willing to take on some credit risk – we believe there may be some appropriate options. For example, the Thrivent Limited Maturity Bond Fund (THLIX) has a very short duration (low interest-rate risk) and has recently offered a yield of 1.55%. The portfolio enhances yield with a diversified portfolio including securitized debt, such as government-guaranteed residential mortgage-backed securities and high-quality structured securities with underlying assets such as corporate and student loans. It also invests in short-term, investment-grade corporate bonds.
The yields for this Fund and the others discussed in this article are based on the distributions paid and the net asset value of the fund. Yields quoted here are “30-day SEC” yields calculated based on the previous 30 calendar days ending June 30, 2020.i For the most recent yields on all Thrivent Mutual Funds fixed-income funds, see: Thrivent Mutual Funds Fixed Income Options.
The same thinking applies to investors who are looking for higher yielding opportunities. One example is the Thrivent Opportunity Income Plus Fund (IIINX). This Fund has relatively short duration (three years) and has recently offered a yield of 2.58%.
A bit more than one-fourth of the Fund is invested in floating-rate leveraged loans, which are bank loans to lower-quality U.S. corporations. They offer a higher yield (currently around 6%) to compensate investors for greater credit risk, such as possible defaults. The Fund also invests in a diversified mix of securitized debt, emerging-markets debt, and corporate bonds, including high yield. Each of these investments carry more credit risk than interest rate risk. We focus on mitigating that risk by conducting extensive research and by diversifying our holdings.
Another approach to balancing interest-rate and credit risk can be seen in the Thrivent Income Fund (LBIIX), which invests primarily in investment-grade corporate bonds. The Fund gets a yield boost by investing in high-yield bonds and other assets classes opportunistically, such as floating-rate leveraged loans and emerging-markets debt. The Fund has less credit risk than Thrivent Opportunity Income Plus Fund but has more than double the duration (seven years). Its recent yield was 2.21%. (See current yield)
Further out in the credit risk spectrum would be a high yield-bond fund. The Thrivent High Yield Fund (LBHIX) invests predominantly in high-yield corporate bonds. For that higher credit risk, it has traditionally paid a higher yield than the Thrivent Income Fund (it was recently yielding 5.63%. (See current yield) We prefer the middle area of the high yield market—B rated bonds—over higher risk CCC bonds (as rated by Standard & Poor’s), because we think the risk tradeoff is better.
Alternative income strategies can also enhance yield by carefully choosing credit risk opportunities. The Thrivent Multidimensional Income Fund (TMLDX) invests in a broadly diversified set of higher yielding debt, including preferred securities. ‘Preferreds’ combine features of debt and equity, in that they pay fixed dividends, but can have a higher potential to appreciate in price. The Fund also invests in closed-end funds and convertible bonds (bonds convertible into equity), both of which carry higher equity-like risk and offer higher potential returns than traditional bonds. The Fund has a relatively short duration of more than four years and was recently paying a yield of 4.21% (30-day SEC yield pre-waiver was 3.76%.ii). (See current rate)
Finally, if you are in a high tax bracket or live in a high-tax state, you may want to consider a municipal bond fund. Municipal bonds are bonds issued by state and local governments to finance public projects such as roads, bridges, schools, and hospitals. The interest they pay is exempt from federal taxes and, in some cases, from state taxes, although any capital gains distributions, as well as realized capital gains from selling fund shares, may be taxable. For certain investors, their after-tax yields can be significantly higher than for other types of bonds.
For example, the Thrivent Municipal Bond Fund (TMBIX) was recently paying a yield of 1.46%. (See current rate) The tax-equivalent yield can be significantly higher (as compared with taxable bond funds), as the graph below illustrates:
We believe that it also makes sense to take strategic credit risks in the muni market, since default rates historically are lower than in the corporate bond market. While the recession has impacted lower-quality municipals, this is reflected in higher yields.
For example, the Thrivent High Income Municipal Bond Fund (TMBIX) has recently paid a higher yield of 3.19% (30-day SEC yield pre-waiver was 2.25%)ii, which may compare favorably to other fixed-income options on a tax-equivalent basis. (See current rate)
While fixed-income yields are still low by historic standards, income-seeking investors can get more return on their investments by taking measured, diversified risks in credit.
The following chart shows the 1-, 5- and 10-year annualized returns of each of the Thrivent Funds fixed income funds discussed in this article:
Keep in mind, this information should not be considered investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or product. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor's specific financial needs, objectives, goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance. We recommend that you consult your tax advisor to make sure you’re getting the most out of your investments. Thrivent employees and their representatives cannot provide legal or tax advice.
All data represents past performance. Past performance does not guarantee future results. The investment return and principal value of the investment will fluctuate so that an investor’s shares, when redeemed, may be worth more or less than the original cost. Current performance may be lower or higher than the performance data quoted. Call 800-847-4836 or visit ThriventFunds.com for performance results current to the most recent month-end.
All information and representations herein are as of 07/21/2020, unless otherwise noted.
The views expressed are as of the date given, may change as market or other conditions change, and may differ from views expressed by other Thrivent Asset Management, LLC associates. Actual investment decisions made by Thrivent Asset Management, LLC will not necessarily reflect the views expressed. This information should not be considered investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or product. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor's specific financial needs, objectives, goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance.
i 30 Day SEC yield is a standardized yield calculation developed by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). It captures the net investment income earned by a fund over a 30-day period, after the deduction of the Fund’s expenses. It’s an annualized percentage, based on the Fund's share price on the last day of the period. Since share prices and yields are subject to fluctuation, current yields should not be considered an indication of future results.
ii This yield calculation is similar to the 30-Day SEC yield but shows what the Fund’s yield would be without any fee waivers or expense reimbursements. Refer to the expense table in the fund’s prospectus for details.
The stock market continued to surge to new records in the 1st quarter, as the vaccine roll-out led to optimism that the economy was on the road to recovery.
The stock market continued to surge to new records in the 1st quarter, as the vaccine roll-out led to optimism that the economy was on the road to recovery.
04/06/2021
Some of the major shifts in the capital markets that began in the 4th quarter of 2020 have continued into the new year – but not in a steady progression.
Some of the major shifts in the capital markets that began in the 4th quarter of 2020 have continued into the new year – but not in a steady progression.
04/06/2021
Despite facing the greatest global health crisis of our generation – and the economic fallout that came with it – the stock market roared to record highs in 2020.
Despite facing the greatest global health crisis of our generation – and the economic fallout that came with it – the stock market roared to record highs in 2020.
03/23/2021
Bond yields took a big leap in recent weeks over inflation concerns, with the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasuries moving up from 1.09% at the end of January to 1.46% at the February close. Rising bond rates in the past have sometimes had an adverse effect on stocks. The more attractive bonds become, as their yields rise, the more likely it is that money will begin flowing out of stocks and into bonds.
Bond yields took a big leap in recent weeks over inflation concerns, with the yield on 10-year U.S. Treasuries moving up from 1.09% at the end of January to 1.46% at the February close. Rising bond rates in the past have sometimes had an adverse effect on stocks. The more attractive bonds become, as their yields rise, the more likely it is that money will begin flowing out of stocks and into bonds.
03/05/2021